Shay's Sweet Treats

Bakery Menu

Explore every muffin, cake, cookie, brownies and more with clear, simple pricing.

Menu

✨ Mix & match flavors

✨ Bulk orders require 72-hour notice

Muffins

Regular or Jumbo

Fresh-baked muffins. Flavors: Blueberry, Cranberry-Orange, Double Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chip and Cinnamon Chip muffin! (Gluten free available on request for additional charge.)

1 Muffin – $3.00 • 3 Muffins – $9.00 • 6 Muffins – $18.00 •12 Muffins – 36.00

Fruit Pastries

Blueberry volcano pastry
Apple crumb pastry
Peach and peach crumb pastry

Tempting fruit-filled pastries lovingly baked with ripe, seasonal fruits and a buttery, flaky crust.

1 Pastry – $3.99 • 6 Pastries – $22.00 • 12 Pastries – $42.00

Legendary Coffee Cake

Buttery, cinnamon-swirled crumb cake that tastes like a warm hug with your morning coffee. Classic Cinnamon — and rotating seasonal flavors inspired by each time of year. Same legendary crumb, new seasonal twist!

  • Blueberry
  • Caramel Apple**Fan-fav
  • Pumpkin Spice
  • Spice
  • Raspberry

Single – $4.99 • Sharable (6.5″×3.5″ Pan) – $9.99 • Pan 8×8 – $14.99 (w/fruit 15.99)

Granola

Small-batch granola in craveable flavors like Honey Nut & Oats and Sweet & Salty — perfect for breakfast bowls, yogurt, or snacking by the handful.

6 oz Bag – $5.00 • 1 lb Bag – $15.00

Pound Cake

Beautifully moist and silky pound cake in many varieties.

Flavors: Blueberry, Vanilla, Orange, Marble, Blueberry Lemon, Almond, Strawberry, Anisette.

Slice – 5oz cake – $4.99

1lb Loaf – $9.99

Cookies

“Grandma-Worthy Goodness“
Crispy at the edges, soft in the middle, and loaded with all the cozy, homemade vibes. One bite and you’ll swear you just got a hug from the inside out.

Flavors: Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter, Ginger Snap, and Ginger Snap (Soft).

Individual Jumbo cookie – $3.50 each

Catering dozen (12 cookies) – $36.00

Small Tray (24 Cookies) – $60.00

Brownies & Bars

Rich, ultra-chocolatey brownies with a perfectly crackled top and a soft, fudgy center that melts in your mouth. Flavors: Fudge, Chocolate & Peanut Butter, or Fudge with Crunchy Nuts.

Brownie – $4.99 • Lemon Bar – $3.99 • Raspberry Crumb Bar – $3.99

9″×9″ Pan (pre-cut) Lemon Bar or Raspberry– $23.99

Add-On Treat Trays — Mixed cookies, bars, brownies and cupcakes

Small (serves 10–12) – $45.00 • Large (serves 20–24) – $82.00

Cupcakes & Cakes

Contact us to discuss flavors and designs.

Pricing available upon request.

Specials

Discover Shay’s rotating seasonal bakes, from pumpkin spice loaves to berry-filled bars and holiday cookies—small-batch treats here for a sweet time, not a long time.

View specials
Order online
An overhead photographic view of a neatly arranged breakfast spread from Shay’s Sweet Treats on a pale blush linen tablecloth: a steaming mug beside a generous slice of crumb-coated coffee cake on a white ceramic plate, a towering jumbo blueberry muffin split open to reveal its moist interior, and a small bowl of toasted granola scattered with dried fruit. Crumbs and oats are casually sprinkled around for a playful, lived-in feel. Soft, diffused daylight from a nearby window casts even illumination with barely-there shadows, creating a clean and airy atmosphere. The composition follows the rule of thirds, with each item carefully spaced to feel abundant yet uncluttered, ideal for a homepage hero image that feels bright, inviting, and deliciously homey.